This idea I learned from Andrew Wilson on force doctrine has stuck with me. What exactly is force doctrine? As I understand it, you are only able to have rights if you have sufficient force to enforce compliance with those rights among the people of the state.
We agree that we should have certain rights, and then we elect the state and give that state a monopoly on violence to protect those rights. Rights themselves are just a set of ideas that help us coexist with each other. Culture defines those rights, and theology defines the culture itself. When Shakespeare said in Hamlet, There’s nothing either good or bad but thinking makes it so, he explained in one sentence the structure of the entire moral world.
We, as conscious beings, attribute the ideas of good and evil to each other while good and evil have no existence outside of our attribution of them. That’s why our idea of reality is subjective, and I’m not sure that objective reality exists at all in any pure form. What I think we call objective reality is the reality we all agree, or approximately agree, is out there. We protect this shared agreement to give ourselves a chance for mutual cooperation under it.
At a certain point, when life becomes comfortable, people begin to deviate from this shared reality into private subjective reality. The idea of personal responsibility can be perverted into the idea that everyone gets to interpret reality through their own emotions. The proper version of personal responsibility is different: you are responsible for your life and your actions, and you adapt your subjective experience to the shared reality the state has been built to protect.
When the shared reality of the state becomes tyrannical, the state tries to subjugate your subjective experience entirely. It confines you to a small role within its framework. You no longer write your own story through personal responsibility because there is no you inside the tyrannical state. There is only a state that writes the story and treats you as the ink with no agency.
The chain runs in one direction. Theology produces culture. Culture produces the framework of personal agency. Personal agency produces personal responsibility. The shared reality that emerges from this chain is then protected through the force doctrine, which defends the rights of the agents the chain produced.
But if the majority of people take their rights for granted as self-evident, they become blind to the force doctrine that produced and protects those rights. They might cede that force to other force doctrines rooted in different cultures sprouted from different theologies. And then their rights will be taken from them, because the force behind those rights has weakened. Without force, you have no rights. All our over-complicated theories of geopolitics are ways to deny our deeply rooted tribal nature.

Leave a Reply